I’m
sad to see that books are still being banned in today’s society.
This
is a week during which attention is drawn to the books that have been censored,
challenged and banned in schools and libraries and during which we also
celebrate the freedom to read whatever we want.
You
might be surprised to find some of your favorite titles topping the list. Here
they are, in no special order.
Reasons:
Offensive language, sexually explicit, unsuited for age group
John
Green has recently risen to internet fame with his YouTube videos and
beautifully written young adult novels. “Looking for Alaska” is one of the
latter. In it, Miles “Pudge” Walter goes in search of something exciting, only
to find exactly what he’s looking for: Alaska Young, a young, beautiful, crazy
girl who steals his heart.
Two
Boys Kissing by David Levithan
An
attempt to break the world record for the longest kiss is at the heart of this
complex novel. The ALA cited challenges focused on ‘homosexuality’ and the
suggestion that the book ‘condones public displays of affection’.
Reasons:
Offensive language, sexually explicit
It
may not surprise you to see E. L. James’ “Fifty Shades of Grey” at the top of
the Banned Books list this year. This popular, erotic fiction series arose out
of “Twilight” fan fiction and has graced the New York Times Bestseller list for
some time. Its sexually explicit scenes is what has this book challenged in
libraries across the nation.
This
autobiographical picture book (co-written with Jessica Herthel) tells how the
activist and YouTube star asserted and embraced her transgender identity.
Reasons given for challenges included the accusation that it was ‘inaccurate’
and ‘unsuited for age group’.
Beyond
Magenta by Susan Kuklin
The
photographer Susan Kuklin interviewed and photographed six transgender teens,
presenting a diverse and complex portrait of lives crossing traditional gender
boundaries. Challenges included the suggestion that it was ‘anti-family’ and
used ‘offensive language’.
The
Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time by Mark Haddon
A
2003 bestseller, this novel follows Christopher as he investigates the death of
his neighbour’s dog, unravelling the emotional and moral confusions of the
adults around him. This sensitive portrayal of a boy on the autistic spectrum
won a host of awards and has faced challenges suggesting it included ‘offensive
language’ as well as ‘profanity and atheism’.
The
Bible
The
Bible joined the ranks of the most challenged books for the first time this
year. According to the ALA challenges to this classic story of wrath and
redemption cited ‘religious viewpoint’.
Fun
Home: A Family Tragicomic by Alison Bechdel
Bechdel’s
graphic memoir of growing up in small-town Pennsylvania explores her
relationship with her father and her own sexuality in a dense spiral of memory
and allusion. Challenges in 2015 included suggestions that it contained
‘violence’ and ‘graphic images’.
Habibi
by Craig Thompson
Thompson
explores child slavery and sexual awakening in a graphic novel that took him
seven years to complete. The ALA logged challenges objecting to ‘nudity’, as
well as suggesting it was ‘sexually explicit’ and ‘unsuited for age group’.
Nasreen’s
Secret School by Jeanette Winter
Winter
depicts life in Afghanistan under the Taliban in this story of a girl who
enrols in a secret school after both her parents disappear. According to the
ALA, challenges included objections to violence and ‘religious viewpoint’.
Have you read any of them? What do you think?
I have of course read the Bible and a couple of the others, but not all. In my library career, it was always a bit traumatic to have a book challenged. It happened several times each year and tended to come in multiples. We followed our policies during the process, policies recommended by ALA. ALA does a great job of guarding the sacredness of freedom to read. Carmen, thank you for showcasing this very important topic. Most people seeking to ban a book don't think of their actions as proposed censorship.
ReplyDeleteI started to think that all this talk about "politically correctness" has simply turned into a kind of Inquisition!
DeleteIf they could ban The Tempest, remember we talked about it sometime ago, nothing males me wonder anymore.
We both love books and reading and as authors ourselves we understand this problem better.
I have of course read the Bible and a couple of the others, but not all. In my library career, it was always a bit traumatic to have a book challenged. It happened several times each year and tended to come in multiples. We followed our policies during the process, policies recommended by ALA. ALA does a great job of guarding the sacredness of freedom to read. Carmen, thank you for showcasing this very important topic. Most people seeking to ban a book don't think of their actions as proposed censorship.
ReplyDelete